Home The Society’s schedule Map of the Month Membership Contact Information
 


Title: The Gerry-mander / A new species of Monster, which appeared in Essex South District in January last

Date: March 27, 1812
Place: Boston, Massachusetts
Source: The Repertory & General Advertiser [newspaper]
Description: Wood engraving, 7¼"[H] x 6¼"[W] plus title.

In early 1812 Massachusetts Republicans engineered a radical redistricting of their state, designed to disadvantage the Federalist majority in the upcoming state senatorial elections. The General Court duly passed the enabling act, which was then signed by Republican Governor Elbridge Gerry. The legislation was enormously controversial and sufficiently unpopular that Gerry was soon voted out of office, though he landed on his feet, being elected as James Madison’s Vice President.

On viewing a map of the redistricted Essex County, one wag – the painter Gilbert Stuart, some say – combined the governor’s name with that of the mythical beast, and so the “Gerry-mander” was born. Soon after the first image of the beast was published, probably in the Boston Gazette of March 26. It consists of a map of one of the two new districts in Essex County, with the constituent towns shown in outline, ornamented by fearsome jaws, claws and a demonic-looking set of wings.

The image was immediately picked up by other Federalist papers, including The Repertory & General Advertiser, whose March 27 rendition is shown here. The text which accompanied this image explained in a mock-serious tone the salamander imagery and conveyed well the vicious partisan politics of the time and the inflammatory role played by the partisan press. It reads in part:

“The district may well be exhibited as a Monster. It is the offspring of moral and political depravity. It was created to drown the real voice of the majority of the citizens of the county of Essex, where it is well known there is a large federal [i.e., Federalist] majority. It is an anti-republican monster; engendered in conclave, during the last session of the Genera[l] Court, with a design to secure power to a few ambitious men…”

The image is unsigned and for many years was attributed to Gilbert Stuart. John Ward Dean’s History of the Gerrymander demonstrated, however, that it was designed by Elkanah Tisdale. Tisdale was a designer and engraver active in New York and Hartford in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.

“Born in Lebanon, Conn., about 1771, and was living in 1834. In 1794-98 Tisdale was located in New York as an “Engraver and miniature painter”; but about the latter year he moved to Hartford and became a member of the Graphic Co., an association of engravers, though he was the designer of vignettes rather than their engraver. Dunlap says that he remained in Hartford until 1825; and that he was designing and engraving plates for Samuel F. Goodrich, of that city, in 1820.

“Tisdale worked in both line and stipple; but his plates possess little merit. The earliest dated plates by Tisdale known to the writer are his full-page illustrations in Trumbull’s ‘McFingal,’ published in New York in 1795.

“Tisdale was a better designer than engraver, and he claimed to be a painter in his early life, though his best work was in the line of miniature portrait painting.” (David McNeely Stauffer, American Engravers on Copper and Steel, I:272-273.)

The Repertory & General Advertiser presentation of the image differs somewhat from the original in The Boston Gazette: Though the monster itself appears to be line-for-line identical, it has been rotated 90 degrees counter-clockwise, and “north” and “south” indicators have been added for the benefit of those Bostonians unfamiliar with the geography of Essex County.

Several years back the Geography and Map Division of the Library of Congress purchased the original Tisdale wood block.

Click here to browse other Maps-of-the-Month